As is the case in the summer, one Reddit user remarked on how they were “dying for the best season at Trader Joe’s,” which is, of course, fall. They went on to say that they love Trader Joe’s pumpkin bagels before asking what everyone else’s favorite fall treats are.

Many fellow Trader Joe’s shoppers commented that they enjoy the Autumnal Harvest Creamy Pasta Sauce, with some going as far as to say this sauce is “the one item [they] hoard, and [they’re] not gonna apologize.” Others expressed excitement over butternut squash mac n’ cheese, pumpkin ice cream, cornbread crisps, and maple butter, which is deemed by many to be a “fall staple.” Still, several recommended Trader Joe’s pumpkin samosas, pumpkin oat milk, and pumpkin brioche.

Even if you are not a fan of pumpkin –- and that’s totally okay! -– there are still plenty of other snacks from which to choose. Other Reddit favorites included Trader Joe’s stuffing-flavored potato chips, maple coffee, fruit and nut crisps, cinnamon bun spread, and Everything but the Leftovers seasonal Everything seasoning. In other words, there is something for everyone.